These resources may help you find reviews and commentary from when your book was first published.
A searchable interface for hundreds of early American newspapers from 1690-1920.
A print index to articles in periodicals from 1802-1906
A searchable database of journal articles about American History
Got citation, need full text?
Print Journal Locations
The print journals are shelved alphabetically by title:
Lewis Reading Room, 1st floor
ground floor "compact" shelves